At present Florida has well over 120 insurance carriers and below you’ll find a list of some of them. Some of the larger carriers are also in position to offer a number of different products at substantially lower rates than some of the others. When trying to decide which car insurance company in Florida you will choose, don’t be afraid to name drop. Once a car insurance company knows that they are in competition with another, the prices on premiums gets better. Car insurance companies in Florida are no different than car insurance companies in any other state. They are insanely competitive with one another and will do what ever they need to do to make sure they get new business.

21st Century
Affirmative
Agency Insurance Company
AIG
AIU
Alfa
Allmerica Financial
Allstate
Alpha Property & Casualty
American
American Bankers
American Federation
American Home Assurance
American Independent
American International
American National
American Reliable
American Security
American Southern Home
American Vehicle
AMEX Assurance
AMICA
Artisan & Truckers
AssuranceAmerica
Auto Club South
Auto-Owners
Bristol West
California Casualty
Cincinnati
Clarendon
Commerce & Industry
Cooperativa De Seguros Multiples
Cornerstone National
Cotton States Mutual
Dairyland
Deerbrook
Direct
Economy
Electric
Encompass
Equity
Esurance
Explorer
Federal
First Acceptance
First Floridian Auto & Home
First Liberty
First National
Florida Farm Bureau
Foremost
Garrison
GEICO
Hanover
Hartford
Horace Mann
Hudson
Illinois National
Infinity
Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania
Integon
Kemper Independence
Liberty Mutual
Lyndon Property
Markel
Massachusetts Bay
Mendota
MeraStar
Mercury
Metropolitan
MGA Insurance
MIC Insurance
National General
National Interstate
National Specialty
National Union Fire
Nationwide
New Hampshire Indemnity
Northbrook
Occidental
Ocean Harbor
Old Dominion
Omni
Owners
Pacific Indemnity
Peachtree Casualty
Peak
Permanent General
Progressive
Property & Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford
Redland
Response
Safeco
Security National FL
Seminole Casualty
Sentinel
Sentry
Shield
Southern-Owners
Star Casualty
State Auto
State Farm
Teachers
Tower Hill
Travelers
Twin City Fire
United Automobile
Unitrin
Universal Casualty
US Security
USAA
Victoria
Windhaven
Workmens Auto